Sugar Hill Restaurant Supper Club

4.1 ( 628 reviews )

Checking... 12:00 AM - 8:00 PM See Hours

217 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, United States

+1 718-797-1727

Nestled in the heart of Bedford-Stuyvesant, Sugar Hill Restaurant Supper Club is a cherished culinary gem that pays homage to the rich history of its neighborhood. With its captivating blend of classic comfort food and modern flair, the establishment serves up hearty dishes like BBQ Pork Ribs and Maryland Crab Cakes, drawing diners seeking flavor and nostalgia. Guests enjoy a welcoming ambiance enhanced by live music and a carefully curated drink selection, including craft cocktails and local beers. With wheelchair accessibility and inviting outdoor seating, Sugar Hill is a vibrant spot for everything from casual lunches to festive dinners, making it a true community staple.

Accessibility
- Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Has wheelchair-accessible seating
Service options
- Has outdoor seating
- Offers delivery
- Offers takeaway
- Serves dine-in
Highlights
- Has fast service
- Has great beer selection
- Serves great cocktails
- Has live music
Popular for
- Popular for lunch
- Popular for dinner
- Good for solo dining
Offerings
- Serves alcohol
- Serves beer
- Serves cocktails
- Serves coffee
- Serves comfort food
- Serves happy-hour drinks
- Serves healthy options
- Serves late-night food
- Quick bite
- Serves small plates
- Serves spirits
- Serves wine
Dining options
- Serves breakfast
- Serves brunch
- Serves lunch
- Serves dinner
- Serves dessert
- Has seating
Amenities
- Has bar on site
- Has toilet
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cosy
- Historic
- Trendy
Crowd
- Good for groups
- Popular with tourists
Planning
- Accepts reservations
Payments
- Accepts credit cards
- Accepts debit cards
- Accepts NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- High chairs available

Gerald Manning

Mar 22,2025

Loved the service from the wait staff, especially Sherry. She was very knowledgeable of the menu options and took great joy in serving us. She's clearly the heart and soul of Sugar Hill. The food was just so well cooked and served with love it felt like down home cooking.

Cody Springer

Mar 15,2025

For the New Yorkers who love to find the spots that feel family owned and nostalgic to the neighborhood - this place is it!!!Or for anyone visiting and missing some good homestyle cooking and southern hospitality - I’m telling you this place is it!!!In the literal best way: it felt like walking into a 90’s movie that takes place in NYC. The white linen tables, the tall wine glasses, the warm wood walls and glitzy mirrors, it’s just soo cute.If you stop by, please ask Sherry to tell you about the 45 year history in its neighborhood, you won’t regret it!Also, if you’re a Harry Styles fan you’ll love this place iykyk ;)

Michael Parisi Presicce

Mar 13,2025

Sugar Hill is a MUST VISIT and bring your friends tooSherry was the best host and told us all about the 45-year history of Sugar Hill and the people who made it special.This beautiful and storied restaurant gives generous portions of southern cooking and incredible service! They are so accommodating and the perfect place for special events. There is a club on the ground floor with karaoke and pool that looks very familiar to a super popular music video iykyk.In a neighborhood that’s rapidly changing, Sugar Hill is an old authentic gem that has kept its shine for decades.

Shaquana L

Mar 4,2025

A spot that has history attached to it. Headed in this spot the day after St. Valentine and wasn’t disappointed. Rose petals and romantic decor was everywhere, beautiful gesture. The food was fresh and tasty, customer service was amazingly delightful with Ms. Sherry and the MIMOSA was my FAVORITE.A great spot for food, drinks, vibe and convo. A total recommendation.

Leo Kim

Feb 8,2025

Had one of the best birthdays of my life here. Such great food, fair prices, and the staff are all beautiful, welcoming characters in their own right.Downstairs has an almost Twin Peaks-y, David Lynch-style bar and banquet room, fully equipped with mirrored walls, red velvet, karaoke, and a light up dance floor. Could probably host a couple hundred peeps here. Never having a birthday anywhere else again haha. Thank you for the golden memories, Eddy, Sherry, and Tasha!!!

dmdm Mochimoti

Feb 5,2025

I came this place to join a count down party in 2016 from Japan.Guessed the organizer took over this restaurant.Why I went there from Japan ?RPR Sound from Romania, they are a DJ group who are well known in underground club music scene. My FAV.Had a very very good time there.Very far from here to Japan.But long distance did not stop me to fly.That was my 1st trip to NYC.

Jennifer Cheng

Jan 18,2025

Literally the best soul food Ive had in nyc. The space is outdated, but in an incredibly charming way. We had the smothered chicken and fried seafood platter - very clearly made with pride and love. Soul food sides were SO GOOD. Proper southern mac n cheese, potato salad, candied yams, and collard greens.Despite being very slow, they presented food properly and some great old fashioned, full table service.I wish i lived closer! Id eat here a lot more.

Rodney Williams

Jan 15,2025

Sugar hill has always been a favorite of mine from the club experience to just going there for dinner. My only wish is that more people frequented this place so it can continue to be maintained because it is truly a staple of bedstuy and one of the last vestiges of the neighborhoods authenticity.

Sugar Hill Restaurant Supper Club

Amenities and More

Photos

Reviews For Sugar Hill Restaurant Supper Club

Add a Review

Location

Appreciated by Others